On July 13, 1973 "Jethro Tull" released its sixth studio album, "A Passion Play".
This album stands as a testament to the band's ambition and willingness to push the boundaries of progressive rock. Building upon the success of their previous epic, "Thick as a Brick", Ian Anderson and his bandmates set out to create their second full-length concept album - a bombastic musical project that would leave a lasting impact. While the album achieved commercial success becoming "Jethro Tull's" second number-one album in the United States, it received mixed reviews from critics, leading to a divided reception among listeners.
The genesis of "A Passion Play" was fraught with challenges and setbacks. Seeking to evade British Crown Income Tax investigators, the band initially relocated to Switzerland and later settled in France's Chateau d'Herouville, a famed recording venue frequented by renowned artists as "Pink Floyd", Elton John and "T. Rex". Amidst technical difficulties, illnesses, and general discontentment, the recordings made in Switzerland and France were ultimately discarded, and the band decided to return to England. This tumultuous journey set the stage for a rushed creative and production process as Ian Anderson, with just 17 days before a new American tour, had to create fresh material and record the entire concept.
Conceptually, "A Passion Play" deviates from the traditional religious "Passion Play" dealing with the life and death of Jesus - a religious hero, by exploring the afterlife journey of a man named Ronnie Pilgrim. The album unfolds as a continuous piece of music, divided into two sides, chronicling Ronnie's funeral, his time caught between life and death, recognizing the old conflict between good and bad, God and the Devil, and finally the return to everyday life. While the album's lyrics are extremely complicated, the story is often unclear, and much is left to the individual's interpretation, the overarching narrative struggles to find cohesion, with Anderson's rushed writing process leading to disjointed sections and fragmented motifs.
Musically, "A Passion Play" presents a fusion of old English folk, classical influences, and of course progressive rock elements. The band exhibits their instrumental prowess with soft acoustic guitars, playful pianos, expressive keyboards, and Anderson's signature vocal delivery. Notably, Anderson experimented with the saxophone, providing a different tonal texture to the music, albeit at the expense of his iconic flute playing. The album showcases "Jethro Tull's" virtuosity and features some memorable melodies, displaying the band's versatility and musicianship.
One notable interruption in the album comes in the form of "The Story of the Hare Who Lost His Spectacles" closing the first side and opening the second side of the vinyl. This spoken-word interlude, musically related with Prokofiev’s Peter and the Wolf, narrated with a humorous English accent by bassist Jeffrey Hammond-Hammond, offers a brief respite from the overall narrative, injecting an element of whimsy into the otherwise weighty themes explored in the album.
Upon its release, "A Passion Play" garnered fierce criticism from both critics and fans. The rushed production process is evident in the album's disjointed nature, lackluster transitions, and underdeveloped arrangements. Critics accused the album of being pretentious, difficult to follow, and musically unengaging. However, it's important to note that the album did achieve commercial success, reaching number one on the charts in the United States, suggesting a divided reception between critics and the general audience.
In retrospect, "A Passion Play" remains a controversial entry in "Jethro Tull's" discography. Some view it as a flawed masterpiece, appreciating its ambitious scope and the band's musical prowess, while others see it as an incoherent and inaccessible work. Regardless of its flaws, the album holds a unique place in the progressive rock canon, representing a period of experimentation and artistic exploration for "Jethro Tull".
For Listening: Spotify, Apple Music